Updated October 23, 2020
Nothing can be as intimidating as buying a GPS running watch. These days there are so many options in features and brands, that researching those options and why they’re important can make your head spin.
Do I need those features? Will they make me a better runner? How much should I spend? I already have a GPS running watch, should I upgrade to a new version? These are all great questions and we hope to answer them for you right here.
At Big Peach Running Co. we only carry Garmin GPS watches. Why just one brand? Garmin has been the leader in GPS running watches, probably because they were one of the first to make running specific watches that had GPS technology, but we also think it has to do with their reliability and customer service.
Not everyone needs a GPS running watch. For decades, a simple watch with a timer/chronograph was sufficient for logging your times if you wanted to keep track of your runs. If you run the same route frequently, a timer is all you need to determine if you’re improving your run times. Most of us, want to know a bit more than time and we like to run different courses or parts of town, so having a way of tracking distance and time conveniently on your wrist is worth the investment.
What features do you need? Most runners starting out will only need 4 features – Time, Distance, Current Pace & Average Pace. So if you’re looking at purchasing a GPS watch, that may be all the features you need right now, but what about the future. If you feel like you’re going to really jump in and take running seriously, then you should consider additional features. We recommend not purchasing a watch with features you need today, instead buy the watch that you’ll need in the future. If you start off with a basic watch and spend $150 today, but next year you’re interested in training with Heart Rate, meaning a new watch for an additional $250. You’ve now spent $400 in the course of a year. It probably would’ve been better to get the $250 watch in the first place. Although it’s hard to predict what you’ll need or want a year from now, consider the additional features and determine if it makes sense to purchase a model with more features than you need right now.
For that runner that’s just getting started, the Garmin Forerunner 45 is a great option starting at $199.99. The benefits of this model are the abundance of features at this price point. It’s easy to use and navigating through the menu doesn’t require you to read the manual from cover to cover to get started. This model’s features include Distance, Pace, and Calories, alerts, menu customization and includes heart rate from the wrist. These days, all GPS watches include the ability to pair with our phone and receive “Smart Notifications” through Bluetooth connectivity. This update now has access to the online Garmin Coach for adaptive training plans. The Garmin Forerunner 45 also serves a regular watch and Activity Tracker that counts your steps throughout the day.
The Venu Sq is the latest entry from Garmin at this price point and directly competes with the FR45 as it has the same functionality but with more. The Venu Sq was released in September 2020 while the Forerunner 45 was released in early Spring 2019. The Venu Sq released 18 months after the FR45 is packed with a lot of features for the same price ($249.99 for the music version) and you’d have to question why you’d purchase the FR45. The style is the only reason that comes to mind. Circular face versus square. The Venu Sq is a full-featured smartwatch that is packed with apps to help monitor your health including a Pulse OX sensor to measure your blood oxygen saturation, a stress tracker, hydration tracker, respiration tracker, sleep monitor, and others. This is all in addition to being a GPS watch with fitness tracking, plus the ability to preload workouts and connects to Garmin Coach for free training plans. What more could you want at a price of $199.99? It’s also available in multiple colors and the music option to stream music from the Venu Sq instead of your phone or another music device.
This is the runner that runs on a regular basis, is consistent with their training (typically following a training plan) and puts races on the calendar. This individual will be looking for more features to help improve their running and achieve better results due to their training. There are several options available to these individuals starting at $300, so which is best?
The Vivoactive 4 doesn’t really fall in line with the rest of the Forerunner line but don’t let that be a reason to overlook this great option. The Vivoactive 4 typically falls in line with the Garmin “Activity Trackers” but it is packed with features (including wrist-based heart rate monitor) that outperform some of the higher-priced models. Compared to the Forerunner 245, it’s a new version that is slimmer and its design doesn’t scream running watch. It can be worn with business attire or out for a run. It also features the newly introduced Garmin Pay so you can leave your wallet at home and pay through the watch. As an activity watch, it is packed with more activity profiles including cycling, weight training, elliptical, stand up paddleboard, swim & rowing just to name a few (including indoor and outdoor profiles). A feature that often gets overlooked is the built-in barometric altimeter that can be only be found on watches costing twice as much. If you like running with music, there’s the Vivoactive Music 4 Music. Music can be loaded onto the watch and paired with Bluetooth headphones for a truly wireless experience.
One of the most highly sought out features, wrist-based heart rate monitor is available on the Garmin Forerunner 245. The optical sensors on the back of the watch measure heart rate without the need for a chest strap, that many, both men and women find uncomfortable. The optical sensors also measure heart rate throughout the day, providing, even more, data including high & low heart rate as well as resting heart rate. The convenience of eliminating the chest strap and going with the wrist-based heart rate brings the price of the Garmin forerunner 245 to $299.99. For an additional $50 you can upgrade to the FR245 Music which allows you to load your favorite music to your watch and pair it with Bluetooth headphones for a complete wireless experience.
The Garmin Forerunner 645 at $399.99 adds features for the runner looking to significantly improve their performance by focusing on running efficiently. This model adds Advanced Running Dynamics, which measures Vertical Oscillation, Ground Contact Time, Balance, Stride Length and Vertical Ratio. To be able to get the additional data, you have to use the higher end heart rate chest strap (also available bundled with the watch). Additional features include Stress Score, Performance Condition, Lactate Threshold, VO2Max and race predictor. If you’re not sure what any of these terms mean, then this is too much data for you. To really take advantage of all this data and use it for training purposes, you really need an experienced running coach that can take that data to design a training program for you. The FR 645 also features Garmin Pay allowing you to leave your wallet at home and pay through your watch. There is also the Forerunner 645 Music for $449.99.
If you’re doing triathlons or considering getting into triathlons, you should consider the Garmin Forerunner 945($599.99). The Forerunner 945 is the latest release and offers everything a triathlete needs. Offering wrist-based heart rate but the Forerunner 945 now only offers 10 hours in regular GPS mode and 60 hours in Ultratrac mode. Battery life has decreased over the previous 935. However, you’re now able to download music to the 945. It also has full-colored, onboard maps to guide you on your runs. It now offers incident detection (when paired with a phone) providing alerts to your emergency contacts.
The Garmin Forerunner 745 is the latest entry for those looking for a multi-sport watch. It’s slightly lighter than the FR945 and noticeably smaller. If you have smaller wrists or prefer a smaller watch, the FR745 is a great option. It offers all of the functionality of the FR945 in a smaller, lighter package without the option to load maps, and it’s $100 cheaper at $499.99.
While there are still additional models that get into the $600+ range like the Fenix 6, the models covered here will be sufficient for 99% of all runners.
While it’s great to have data to see how much we have improved in our running, don’t become obsessed with the data. We’ve found that some of our best runs have been when we’ve forgotten our GPS running watch and enjoyed running in it’s purest form, being able to take in the sights and sounds through the neighborhood, with no worries about our speed, pace or distance. Running is supposed to be fun after all!